Fern asked:
Dear All, this is a bit of an off track query after a stormy night. What significance does rain have in K-dramas and C-dramas? It always shows up and seems to be like another character. Does it always represent tears or drama or an excuse to huddle together under an umbrella, or can it have other meanings?
You’re right, Fern. Kdrama can’t be a legit drama without a rain scene. Off the top of my head, I can list 10 uses of rain in an Asian drama.
1. For “Pathetic fallacy”
*I’m not a literature major, so don’t kill me if I get this literary device wrong.
The weather is supposed to match the mood of the characters. So if the characters are lonely and depressed, then the clouds have to weep with them. The raindrops represent the tears.
2. To highlight the first meeting
First meetings in kdramas have to be memorable.
We saw Gong Yoo meeting his bride in “Goblin” in the rain. Ha! For the girl, this was their first meeting. She didn’t know that he’d appeared before her even before then (remember? her first crush was the baseball player and Gong Yoo ruined his game…hahaha).
The first encounter in “Temptation of Wolves” has often been parodied.
And we had the “cute-meet” in “Extra-ordinary You” between Eun DanOh and Haru. (It wasn’t really raining…but we got the message).
The central message of an accidental meeting on rainy day: the couple are fated for each other.
3. To promote the yellow umbrella
The yellow umbrella is ubiquitous in kdramas. There must be some folklore or old wives’ tale about the auspiciousness of the color yellow that I haven’t heard because yellow is the preferred color of umbrellas in kdramas.
Here it is in “Love Rain.”
In “Tomorrow, With You” the couple married on a rainy day. Yellow umbrella included.
Here’s the yellow umbrella in “She Was Pretty”:
And the yellow umbrella in “Missing You.”
I remember a scene in “He’s Psychometric” where all the umbrellas that paraded past the hero were either yellow or red. Apparently, those colors were the girl’s favorite…or something like that.
In “Splash Splash Love,” the King (played by Yoon DoJoon) reincarnated and showed up at Seulgi’s side. I interpreted the yellow umbrella as a sign that the couple’s separation was only short-lived, and they had a bright future ahead of them.
But any color of umbrella will do, if shared with pretty boy, Cha Eun Woo,
From “My ID is Gangnam Beauty”:
or offered by Lee Min Ho.
From “Legend of the Blue Sea” which is another drama written by the CLoY writer.
I wouldn’t mind a starry starry umbrella if Yoo SeungHo came with it. lol.
From “I’m Not a Robot”:
Of course, if there are no umbrellas in sight, the orange cone works just as well.
From “Pinocchio”:
4. To praise the man’s shoulder
The rain scene shows that —
a. the man has enviable broad shoulders. The two of them won’t fit under the umbrella.
From “Jugglers”:
b. the man is protective of the woman. He’ll shield her because he wants her to stay dry.
From “Love O2O”:
The rain scene in Love O2O had the effect of making me swoon like an adolescent fangirl. #sorrynotsorry.
5. To push a sexist trope
The girl is a weakling. She’ll catch pneumonia when she gets rained on.
I’m melting.
6. To show the height differential
Kdrama viewers are in love with a tall guy-short girl coupling, and there’s nothing as cute as a mushroom being sheltered by a tall tree.
From “Abyss”:
But it’s okay too when the guy’s short. It’s the thought, not the height, that counts.
From “When the Camellia Blooms”:
7. To show love even when he’s angry or petulant
This poster from “Angel’s Last Mission: Love” was a total rip-off.
credit: soompi
from this one famous illustration.
From “Page Turner” — hahaha. It was actually snowing here but I like the actor here.
Then there’s “Flower Crew: Joseon Marriage Agency.” He didn’t like her looking pathetic in the rain so he ordered he to get up.
8. To increase the viewers’ angst
Rain is used by the writer to raise the emotional stakes and to boost up empathy for the character. It’s an “acceptable” form of psychological manipulation.
You see, if the girl gets rained on because the guy wasn’t there to protect her from the rain, AND SHE DIES, then it’s all the guy’s fault.
From “Dr. Cutie.” He ordered her to kneel the whole day, then left her out in the rain. So when she fainted, he was “mentally tortured” — or something. We’re supposed to feel her pain (tears) for his callous disregard of her health.
And what about this scene from “Moon Lovers: Scarlet Heart Ryeo”? I don’t know what this scene is all about but doesn’t he just look like the devil guarding a sad angel here?
And this, from “Fated to Love You (2008)” the Chinese version. I never hated rain so much in a drama. It was a baby-killer.
And so her unborn baby died.
When it comes to angst, Cdramas use rain to a more dramatic effect than Kdramas.
9. Big kiss?
Unlike Hollywood moves, the rain in kdramas and cdramas seldom builds up to a steamy make-out session. So far, rain scenes in Asian dramas haven’t been hyper-sexualized yet.
If ever, the skinship brought about by the rain is swoon-worthy rather than arousing. Case in point: the shower scene from “Flower Crew: Joseon Marriage Agency.” Gifs from lavenderbyun’s tumblr.
10. Rain is spiritually cleansing, healing and refreshing.
More often than not, rain in Asian dramas is depicted as heaven’s way of blessing mortals with a moment of their own to simply breathe and enjoy being a couple.
So there you go, my 10 uses of rain in an Asian drama. Feel free to add your own. 🙂
**********
02/20/20 Edited to add this. Thanks @barbrey.
The Yellow Umbrella in “How I Met Your Mother.”
The Yellow Umbrella is an object originally owned by The Mother, which comes into the possession of Ted after she leaves it at a party. It is often used to represent her since she remains faceless. Its significance was first mentioned during Wait For It.
The story of the Yellow Umbrella begins in the episode No Tomorrow. It was St. Patrick’s Day and Barney and Ted went to a party, the mother was also at that party carrying the yellow umbrella with her at the entrance. After a wild night at the party, Ted got punched in the face for charging drinks to someone else’s account. After that Ted tells Marshall what happened that night, and tells him that he forgot his phone, so Ted went back to the party to look for his phone but couldn’t find it. He was just about to leave, but it was raining, so he went back in and found the yellow umbrella. He took the umbrella and left.Later on in the episode Right Place, Right Time, Ted got a job to design a restaurant shaped like a cowboy hat. He told the guys from Rib Town that they picked the right guy and that he could do it easily, but he couldn’t do it at all and thought that it was a ridiculous design. Robin then tells him that he needs to get out of the house and get a bagel, and that he should take an umbrella with him because it was going to rain. He took the yellow umbrella with him and has it when he meets Stella on the street. The meeting would eventually result in Ted getting a teaching job at Columbia University, where the Mother sees him for the first time. In the episode Girls Versus Suits, Ted brings the yellow umbrella to Cindy’s apartment and leaves it by the door when he comes inside. When he leaves, he forgets to take it with him, and abandons it where its original owner, Cindy’s roommate and The Mother, will find it.
In Big Days, Ted is seen attending a wedding, which turns out to be Barney’s, in 2013, after which he will meet the mother. As it rains, he tells Marshall that he didn’t bring an umbrella, a reference to the mother’s yellow umbrella he obtained years beforehand.
In No Pressure, after Ted gains closure with Robin, he walks outside to everyone outside with a yellow umbrella. This symbolises his opportunities after he gets over Robin.
In Farhampton, in a flashforward, while Ted is waiting at the Farhampton train station for a train after Barney and Robin’s wedding, The Mother comes out of a taxi, holding up the yellow umbrella in the rain and stands a few feet from Ted.
In Something New, The Mother is seen carrying her bass guitar and yellow umbrella in a train station. She walks up to the counter and asks for a ticket to Farhampton where she will be playing in the band on Barney and Robin’s wedding.In How Your Mother Met Me, almost every near chance encounter between The Mother and Ted, including every event involving the The Mother’s umbrella, are finally tied together and explained from her perspective.
In Last Forever – Part Two, it is revealed that the umbrella bears the initials T.M. on its handle. Ted notices this when he meets the mother, leading the two to recall the story of how the umbrella had been lost and regained. The exchange inadvertently causes them to introduce each other by their first and last names, since they both have the same initials.
source: https://how-i-met-your-mother.fandom.com/wiki/Yellow_Umbrella
Thank you, @packmule3.
Ah, I didn’t know the yellow umbrella was a thing. I haven’t been watching dramas long enough. In ‘The Secret Life of my Secretary’ she produced a yellow umbrella on their first date. He kept it and only had to look at it when they broke up to start crying.
It’s funny because in Temptation of Wolves she never dated him. She’s in love with the other guy (that gave a another famous scene for this movie : the kiss scene)
The one in Extraordinary You was beautifully filmed.
For She Was Pretty, the Renoir’s umbrella was so better!
Something in the Rain had great scenes under the rain and the color of the umbrellas changed during the story.
I think it’s very usual in Asia, the rain is something romantic. There are a lot of animated movie with rain and umbrellas too.
With rain considered so romantic, no wonder they all lose it at the first snow!
In Something in the Rain, if I remember correctly, the falling-in-love umbrella he used was red, the I’ll-never-forget-you umbrella he kept was green, and the grand-reunion-at-the-end umbrella was yellow. Guess the writer wasn’t thinking about the order of those colors in our stoplights!
I think another category for Rain Meanings should be My-Life-is-a-Disaster melancholy.. like in Romance Is a Bonus Book’s first or second episode, when the homeless, shoe-less Dan-i gets drunk on the sidewalk outside the wedding-dress store.
Thanks for this @packmule3.
THE REASONS FOR UMBRELLAS
As usual I’m amazed that you managed to pull out at a drop of a hat, so many yellow umbrella scenes and the dramas that go with each. I only ever thought of a few very staid reasons for umbrellas, of any colour, and by association, one of the reasons for rain (ie it’s an excuse to take out the umbrella, LOL), and I can’t recall most of the dramas!
If only 1 party of the couple has it, the umbrella is used to bring the other party within an arm’s length to have them close beside one, to demonstrate who’s protecting whom and the dynamics of the relationship. For eg. when the girl is offered an umbrella by someone she does not like, she prefers to run off in the rain without taking it.
Or conversely, even though she does like the guy, she runs off without the umbrella, and it becomes the excuse to see her again. That happened in the Secret Life of My Secretary. In that same show, it showed the change in the relationship where previously she’d be the one to hold the umbrella over him while she got wet, and then we get the reverse when he finally sees her as a woman and not just his employee.
In a show like Big, the umbrella is used to hide the face (and frustrate the viewer), but since the guy comes with the umbrella for the girl, it signifies that it’s him. Similarly in Splish Splash Love, I believe … but we do get to see his face and he returns her umbrella to her.
If both parties each have an umbrella, then they come together (again) from living their separate lives as in Summer Scent, and somehow the umbrella (and their loudly beating hearts) help them recognise each other. LOL 😆
Good point on the umbrellas being used as a relationship indicator. Somebody mentioned it earlier, too.
Yes, in “Splish Splash Love” DoJoon was the guy in the first scene, right? She didn’t notice him and the viewers weren’t shown his face.
@GB and @packmule3, thank you for this. Whether it’s umbrellas, a cape, a traffic cone or a dry car, it sounds like a plot device and a good excuse for a relationship indication as you said @packmule3.
See? Your wish is our command. You asked about the rain, and we answered. 😂
There are other rain scenes, I remember.
Mischievous Kiss.
Now the rain there was part of the ending, and I remember how I wanted the girl to tell him to get out of her life. But he came to look for her in the rain and he had brought an umbrella for her. So… 🤷♀️ she forgave him and they kissed.
The ending wouldn’t have worked without the rain. It was integral to the plot.
Full House.
With Rain (the actor) and Song Jiho (Song Joonki’s ex). Rain berated her for staying up all night waiting for him. She walked out. It started to rain. He worried about her and went searching for her on the beach.
Meanwhile, she was out in a park somewhere. When the rain started, she sought shelter in a phone booth (remember those? Lol) and she called up the second male lead. HE came with the umbrella and brought her to his home. While she slept on his couch, he decided he’d step in and challenge Rain. 🙂
The rain was a turning point.
You’re welcome @Fern.
Ah yes, @pkml3 Full House… 2nd male lead thought 1st ML had left FL out in the rain and decided he had a winning chance with her. (I believe you mean Song Hye Kyo as FL in Full House). I thought that ML did too much shouting and running off. There wasn’t much meaningful together time with FL, except that they had meals together or fought. Thank goodness the later dramas do not follow exactly the same long-windedness in the progression of the romance and the trite conflict making of ML running off to 2nd FL at every point when he should have been with FL. I feel that if I were to watch the show now, I’d throw something at Rain and the 2nd FL. 😫 😒 😆
Ooops. Yes. It’s Song HyeKyo. (Who’s Song JiHo?? Did I just invent a name there? lol)
Full House was 99% makjang. Soap-opera-ish. I remember the rain scene and Rain charging in there to get his wife, playing the possessive husband after he spent the whole night with the clingy female lead AND told Song HyeKyo that she had no right to interfere with his life. That got my hackles up.
That whole angsty, love-me-hate-me, love triangle is outdated. They didn’t age well.
I never liked Full House. They always put the “honeymoon” flashbacks for their happy moments when they didn’t really know each other at this moment and SHK was always cleaning the house…
But the thai version is really good and the actors had a way better chemistry.
Now that you mentioned it, you’re absolutely right!! I don’t get the honeymoon flashbacks either. It bugged me that it was the “highlight” of their romance when they were merely tolerating each other that time.
I also don’t understand that whole “Papa Bear, Mama Bear, Baby Bear” nursery rhyme. It hurt my eyes to watch Rain do aegyo while singing “Baby Bear” to appease an angry Song HyeKyo.
IIRC “Mischievous Kiss” was done in Thai, too. I like the explanation of the guy’s behavior with the girl. He wasn’t a jerk (or at least from the couple of episodes that I saw) like the Korean version.
Mischievous Kiss has so many versions. I liked the Thai one too. I don’t remember very well the Korean one, I guess I was still revolted that Jung So Min killed Kim Nam Gil in Bad Guy 😀
Great post! Some symbolism for you: a yellow umbrella often was the official shade for a monarch in Asia (I just know this from watching movies) and of course yellow umbrellas are also symbolic of the Umbrella Revolution in Hong Kong (possibly a shout out by some of these directors in solidarity). And then there’s the meme from How I Met Your Mother – someday I’ll find my yellow umbrella (lost love), which showed up when I googled it trying to find the royalty symbol history. One or more of these might be responsible for the ubiquity of the yellow umbrella! Or none of them, lol.
Thanks, Barbrey.
I heard of “How I Met Your Mother.” Was the umbrella scene at the beginning of the series? It began in 2005 and didn’t end till 2014.
The earliest use of yellow umbrella I know in kdrama (and I don’t know much about this) was in “Love Rain,” televised in 2012.
I’ll post the HIMYM fandom’s explanation of the yellow umbrella on the blog.
“there’s nothing as cute as a mushroom being sheltered by a tall tree.“
Ah. You made me laugh. Thank you.
I think it just rains a lot in Korea so they use it for dramatic effect.
Pingback: Psycho But It’s Okay: What’s With the Rain? – Bitches Over Dramas