Love Scout: Ep 2 On Romantic Scenes, part 2

To bookend my review of these first two episodes, I’ll finish in the same way I began: with an example of a romantic scene I approve of. This time, I’ll focus on the cinematography.

The backstory:

A furious JiYoon (JY) marches into her sunbae’s office. She accuses her former colleague of poaching her candidates to hurt her. She tells Sunbae to stop the scheming or else, she will assume Sunbae is terrified of her. But Sunbae counters that of course, she’s terrified of JY because one person already died because of her.

With that comeback, Sunbae does two things. One, she admits to stealing JY’s recruits. But she claims that her actions weren’t unethical nor shameful because they were in retaliation for JY’s past offence. Two, she triggers JY’s memories.

JY’s eyes shift down to her sunbae’s nameplate on the desk and she’s instantly transported back in time when she was looking at another man’s nameplate on an empty desk. The CEO of the company had passed away and her coworkers were buzzing about her role in his death.

Clearly, the sunbae knows JY’s Achilles’ heel. To JY’s credit however, she steels herself to issue a final warning to her sunbae. “If you do this again, I won’t hold back anymore.” Then, she marches walks out of her sunbae’s office.

Once she’s out of there, she hears people whispering around her.

Note how the camera becomes blurry. Though it keeps JY in focus, everything around her is hazy, cloudy, foggy. This is great camerawork because it gives the impression that:

— JY’s walking in a daze. She can’t clearly see the people around her because she has disconnected from the physical world and withdrawn to her mental world. This retreat to her inner thoughts is her way of coping with stress. Remember the child Byeol’s drawing of a girl engulfed in black? This is something similar: JY is engulfed in fog.

— JY’s isolated and abandoned. Everyone is blathering that she’s a traitor and that she was shameless to show up there after her betrayal. In this shady world, nobody is on her side. The bleakness of the shot captures the unforgiving and judgmental nature of the workplace.

— JY’s living in a déjà vu. The monochrome of this scene aptly produces a surreal feeling of “been-there, done-that.” Her traumatic past merges with the present as she heads for the exit. In her imagination, she’s reliving the “perp walk.” In reality, however, no one is paying attention to her. A female stranger even bumps her because she’s on the phone. If ever, JY’s attracting attention because she’s walking as if she’s a zombie.

Note the different camera angles in this last scene. I’ll explain five different angles for expedience.

1. The wide shot. This sets the stage and provides visual context.

2. The close-up shot. This focuses our attention on a particular action that we might have missed with a wide shot.

3. This POV shot. This gives us the perspective of the character. For example, when the camera is positioned behind the back JY, we’re virtually standing in her shoes and seeing what she’s seeing. This camera angle allows us to empathize with her emotions.

4. The medium close-up. This allows us to watch the character react to the dialogue or events.

Let’s begin at 1:00:57, the moment when JY steps away from Career Way.

First, there’s a close-up shot of JY’s shoes as she crosses the threshold. Career Way’s office has a carpet with hexagonal design. Outside is white marble. To me, these details are symbolic. Those hexagons gives off a claustrophobic vibe, that is, a feeling of being hemmed in. In contrast, the white marble appears liberating. JY is leaving her former workplace which had been hostile to her in the end, and heading off on her own. The future is uncertain, though.

Then, there’s a medium close-up of JY looking exhausted. Though she mustered enough courage to enter her enemy’s territory, she’s now drained of energy. There’s also a droning noise in the background which probably mimics the ringing in her ears because she’s feeling faint.

Then, a POV shot. JY sees strangers before her, and they appear unfriendly and unwelcoming. She gets bumped by one of them.

Next, a close-up shot of JY grasping her head and blinking her eyes. This tells us that she’s getting more and more confused. She feels faint but is trying to hold onto consciousness.

Then, there’s a medium close-up of JY walking past pillars. I like this super-imposed imagery because it gives the sense that she has a long way to go before exiting the building.

Next, a wide shot of JY entering an airy, glass-filled hall. This is symbolic again. She may have escaped danger but she’s in a vast emptiness with no exit and no end in sight.

Then, close-up shot of JY grabbing the railing. This is her desperation. She’s at the end of her rope but must hold on.

source: iamacolor’s tumblr

Then, we get a wide shot of JY with the backdrop of a glass wall. There are lines everywhere in this shot. The lines frame her in a corner, looking small, insignificant, and helpless.

Then, the camera gives us a close-up of her eyes as she looks down at the ground floor. From this shot, we see her point-of-view. We get that the wide-open space is frightening. How will she get down and out of there when she’s feeling dizzy and lightheaded? Who will help her out? No one is there. But then, in the corner of her eye, she spots someone entering the grand hall and running up the escalators.

source: iamacolor’s tumblr

Then, there’s a close-up of her face. It shows her confusion and disbelief.

I like the camera following EH up the escalator.

source: iamacolor’s tumblr

He takes three steps at a time because he’s in a hurry to reach her side. I’m reminded of the “rocky staircase” scene in Episode 1. Although he wasn’t in a hurry back then to rescue her from the darkness, I thought he was purposedly clomping down the stairway so the sound of his heavy footsteps would reassure her that help was on the way. (I wrote this in passing, didn’t I?)

Noteworthy: the difference in camera focus.

When the camera is focused on EH, the shot is hazy and blurry at the edges, and the colors are filtered and muted. That’s because we’re seeing him from JY’s eyes, and she’s about to lose consciousness.

source: iamacolor’s tumblr

However, when the camera is focused on JY, the shot is sharp, and the color is back. That’s because we are looking at her from EH’s eyes, and he’s clear-headed.

source: iamacolor’s tumblr

Next, a close-up shot of JY reaching out to him.

Then, a wide shot of EH’s running to her side.

source: iamacolor’s tumblr

Then, a close-up of EH grasping her arm as she clutches his. As soon as they touch, the colors return. Like magic.

source: iamacolor’s tumblr

What follows next is multiple close-up shots of JY and EH. As I said earlier, close-up shots are meant to indicate action. Therefore, even though only one word is uttered (EH says, “Taepyonim” or “Ms. CEO.”), there’s a whole lot of INTERNAL  movement — or realizations — going on. They’re both processing what this whole encounter means to them because it isn’t merely by accident that he appeared at her side.

Moreover, I think there’s a subtle callback to the “nondualism gate” in Ep 1. Although there isn’t a physical “nondualism gate” behind them, the fact that she rests on him, and he lets her be, is the ultimate SIGN of nondualism. Meaning, she’s freed herself of her binary worldview of love and hate, I’m-right-you’re-wrong, client and non-client, boss and assistant, friend and enemy, etc. And she rested on him.

Their body position alone evokes the symbol of nondualism and oneness: yin and yang.

(sorry, I can’t get a better screenshot than this.)source: iamacolor’s tumblr

Non-duality Part II: Yin-Yang – Julie A. Nelson

And that’s why I say this is a romantic scene, although it isn’t melodramatic like the she-fell-off-the-cliff scene in  “When the Phone Rings” or she’s-hanging-on-the-ledge scene in “My Demon.”  The romance is the result of a well-planned and carefully executed cinematic presentation of an otherwise trope-y event of a man rescuing a fainting damsel.

10 Comments On “Love Scout: Ep 2 On Romantic Scenes, part 2”

  1. Thank you, @packmule3. I have to say that because I dislike heights, JY’s grasping the railing high above the lobby gave me the chills. I was worried that she might faint, be shoved or otherwise end up bead first on the ground floor. I wondered if EH may have felt the same dread seeing her, which brought on his sprint up the escalator towards her.

    The yin yang symbol is even duplicated in their attire. A great metaphor.

  2. Awesome review! I am applauding inside! It’s amazing you can articulate all that after watching. Really great. I’m actually really enjoying this drama even if I don’t know either of the leads and the ML isn’t quite handsome for me. He’s really good at this silent, efficient body guard type role though. Like Ju Ji hoon in Bloodfree but sunnier.

  3. @packmule 🍪🍪🍪. Beautifully put. EH took 3 steps at a time because he was running up the DOWN escalator 😂😂😂. I thought I was mistaken when I first saw it (and I checked it again and it was definitely the down escalator) because it wasn’t as if the UP escalator was crowded with people. They were both void of people. PD specifically got him to run up the DOWN escalator. Akin to him going against the tide (of expectations) to be by her side.

    I went to check up on this PD’s previous work but unfortunately I didn’t watch any of them – Wok of Love, My Strange Hero. Both of these were released in 2018 and thereafter (according to AsianWiki) he seemed to have gone on a hiatus. He returns to the field with this drama.

  4. @Packmule – I so enjoyed the way you captured – slowed down and analysed- these key moments. [I also enjoyed your write-up of the romance of the hillside steps!]

    I really enjoyed this precarious scene the first time I saw it. I was looking out for EH. Then I thought he wasn’t coming and she was on her own clinging to a guard rail. Then someone came into sight wearing a light suit! I wasn’t clear if he was just another passer by in the scene. Huge sense of relief when I realised it was EH purposefully rushing up the escalator towards her. It was clever the way we didn’t assume rescue at this point because we had the heroine’s point of view.

    So much loving care and thought has gone into creating these unforgettable moments. This show appeals to a K-drama aware audience. We know the currency of K-dramas and we like it when we see something beautifully crafted.

  5. Thanks, @nrllee. I wondered about the escalator but didn’t have time to double-check it. I’m glad you did. We’re into tiny details like that. 🤣🤣

    I guess in his rush to get to her, he just took the nearest escalator to the entrance. Hmm… how did he guess where she was?

    I heard of “Wok of Love.” Junho is in it but I wasn’t into cooking-themed kdramas back then so skipped it.

  6. @Fern,

    I admit — when by myself, I avoid looking over balcony railings or walking on the edge of a cliff. I’m afraid that I’ll heed the abyss calling my name and jump off.

    When I’m with others, I’m fine with heights. I guess, I feel safe that they’ll stop the thrill-seeker in me from doing crazy stunts.

    Weird, I know.

    I once entered a cage to pose with alligators. My husband/then-boyfriend was beside himself (Literally. He was too scared to join me.)

  7. @packmule3, yes, it’s worse when I’m alone, too. It’s as though the floor tilts slightly. Ewwww.

    One of the worst was a one-lane road in Tenerife, going around Mount Teide. There was a tourist bus coming from the other direction and, no, it wouldn’t stop at a wide spot. Instead, my husband had to back up until we finally got to another wide spot. He was on the uphill side of the road, while I had a great view of the abyss next to me. I would gladly have filled that bus with alligators rather than tourists!

  8. @Fern I think when there are others with you, your brain registers where they are at and the floor levels as a result. When you’re on your own, there are no other reference points and your brain just believes what it wants to 😂😂… But I get you completely. I avoid cliff edges. I don’t dare peer over them – not unless I am prostrate and crawling 😂😂😂. I can’t do those clear glass bridges over cliffs. It’s not natural to have clear sight of the cliff below your feet.

    @packmule I had to do a check with the escalators because with that shot of him running up (and camera behind him), the PD slowed it clip down and it was hard to work out if it was just an optical illusion (he’s running up so the escalator may appear to be going down relative to his movement). But in the subsequent shot of the pair of them at the top as he’s grabbed her outstretched hand (and they are motionless), you can see clearly in the background that the escalator was indeed moving down. 😂😂😂. Yes I am into details. It makes the viewing so much more enjoyable. And yes I was wondering how he knew where she was too. Did he follow her? I think he was already concerned when she seemed unwell that day (and she refused to eat lunch). She was annoyed at him back at the office for his well intentioned offer of medicine. She tipped the bottled water over her desk full of files and she yelled at him for “doing useless things” (by this she meant caring for her welfare). I think she doesn’t like his attentiveness because it just shows her ineptitude when it comes to self care. She has no love for herself. He took it upon himself to shadow her in case she passed out or something.

  9. GrowingBeautifully (GB)

    @pkml3, thanks for putting so much effort into breaking down what makes a scene romantic.

    What you say about the drawing of Byeol: @Fern and I were considering that an equivalent of it could also be seen in how JY is surrounded by darkness in her own home, and now as you and @Fern say, we see it in her mind where scenes are foggy. I felt that the times everything became fuzzy were her memories of the bad experiences she suffered in Career Way or the show’s depiction of the state of her mind.

    Watching that scene again, I noticed that for the first time, JY takes a few faltering steps towards EH before he grabs her arm. That’s a great concession from the unyielding CEO and traumatised ‘child’ who avoids being hurt by not making personal contact with anyone except MA.

    Since you mention wide angled shots, I looked again and see that we get the wide-angled ending scene with her resting on EH’s shoulder. It shows them surrounded by vertical lines (divisions) on all sides but the two of them are framed nicely together in 1 window pane. Despite the divisions and obstacles they not separated.

    Then the camera pans upwards from a distance, showing the fore front where the horizontal bars of the near railing move downwards from our perspective. It looks like EH and JY are standing alone but moving up together, as they had done in the lift. A hopeful point in a fraught relationship.

  10. When JY stumbled out of Career Way onto that balcony far above the lobby floor, then gripped the balustrade, I feared she was in a state of mind to toss herself over the rail. Was this a hint as to how her former, deceased CEO died? Kudos to the director and cinematographer of this show for making JY’s inner experience so palpable to viewers.

    I, too, have experienced brief, intrusive thoughts of jumping when standing at a height. I was relieved to learn this is something commonly experienced, and has been given the name High Place Phenomenon (HPP).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *