I’ve made fun before of tropes in kdramas. Now, it’s cdramas’ turn, in particular, historical cdramas.
This is a work in progress. Feel free to contribute.
1. The princess carry
I dare you to name a cdrama where the hero did NOT princess-carry the girl at least once.
source: heymeowmao’s tumblr
This scene from “Prisoner of Beauty” is a headscratcher for me. Man Man’s nanny told Wei Shao that she was running a high fever but he still picked her up and carried her in the rain back to his residence. Good thing she didn’t catch pneumonia after that.
2. Presence of rain when a couple separates, breaks up, dies, etc.
Thank goodness there’s no yellow umbrella like in kdramas.
3. Bathtub brooding
I made fun of shower scenes in kdramas but cdramas are just as bad. Instead of showers, the male lead soaks in a tub filled with rose petals. (I get that the petals are a convenient way to hide his private parts, but come on now, no guy wants to smell of roses after a bath.)
At least, Wei Shao had ice floating in his tub.
source: smittenskitten’s tumblr
Of course, with the bathtub brooding trope, there’s an obligatory camera shot of the abdominal muscles.
4. Concubine issues
But this is historically accurate, though.
Google AI says there was only ONE Chinese emperor who didn’t take a concubine and insisted on being monogamous: Emperor Hongzhi aka Zhu Youcheng of the Ming Dynasty. He apparently loved his wife so he refused to marry a concubine. In cdramas, the male lead – if he’s in a leadership position – is always forced to take a concubine.
5. Loyal maid
If the heroine is royalty, there she has a resourceful and loyal maid to do everything for her, even whipped up a full course meal late at night.
The maid should have a story of her own.
6. Pretty floral snacks
In kdramas, there’s always a ramen scene. In historical cdramas, there’s always a floral cookie or two served.
7. A brother (or cousin) in love with the same girl
Historical cdramas often feature sibling rivalry.
Could this perhaps be the government way of touting the benefit of their one-child policy, that is, the only child has no pesky sibling to compete with him for the girl?
8. Dramatic death or near-death scene
The primary source of conflict in historical cdramas is the palace/political intrigue. There’s always somebody plotting to assassinate either the male or female lead.
With cdramas, the happy ending is never guaranteed. There’s a 50/50 chance that the hero (or heroine) dies in the final episode.
9. Poison and blood vomit
It’s come to point that whenever there’s ominous background music and the female/lead lead is about to drink from a cup, I expect her/him to writhe in pain or keel over in the next scene.
Naturally, after the poison comes the blood vomit. I do wonder what the budget is for red dye for these historical cdramas.
10. The moon as silent witness to the couple’s lovey-dovey moment
Just like rain is ubiquitous during heartbreak scenes, the sky is always moonlit when the couple is about to engage in physical intimacy.
First, the camera focuses on the kissing couple, then instead of simply fading to black, it pans to the moon in the sky. I’m sure the darkness enhances the romantic ambiance. But I think the other message is what happens in the dark, stays in the dark…because the moon can’t talk.
11. Fireworks
As the Chinese can claim bragging rights to the invention of fireworks, I understand the use of fireworks in romantic moments.
12. Jade
I don’t know if jade is a curse or gift, but there’s always something bad involving a jade object that the hero/heroine must deal with. You can’t make me buy a jade bracelet.
13. Running on tiled roofs
Anybody can be a ninja in cdramas because of the wireworks. But this rooftop running trope attests to the superiority of the hero’s martial skills that he appears to be flying like a god in the skies, unrestricted by gravity.
14. Calligraphy
Calligraphy is an indicator of refinement and moral character so at least one of the leads must demonstrate elegant calligraphy. I love the scene in “Are You the One” when the hero teaches the girl calligraphy after her wrist tendons were cut. Lol. It reminded me of that iconic pottery scene in “Ghost” but a whole lot less steamy.
15. Kneeling as punishment/atonement/petition
It’s more dramatic when done in the rain.
16. Face-slapping
I think this trope is more common in cdramas than in kdramas. In kdramas, it has been parodied and mocked so often (remember that kimchi slap?) that it lost its significance. In cdramas, however, face-slapping is still considered an acceptable way of retaliating an injustice or grudge.
17. Dreaming as an alternative to reincarnation
Since China censors rebirth as a plot device, the screenwriters must come up with novel ways, like dreaming to explain time-travel, transmigration, or reincarnation in the story.
Another similar trope is waking up to find oneself in a comic book or ancient text.
18. Over-the-top hairpieces
source: yilinglaozu’s tumblr
Will add more later.
I find, after watching Love Like the Galaxy, that many historical cdramas I watched after that follow the same pattern. Youthful Glory and Prisoner of Beauty included. Unapproachable, broody, socially inept- even chaste martial god ML meets FL who is always a mix of youth, and/or unruliness plus business acumen.
They may be repetitive but I’m quite addicted!
Lantern Festivals!
Candied hawthorn sticks
Unjust imprisonment of someone honourable
Following on from Nicole – the FL setting up a shop (cosmetics, fabric, food)
Light hearted second male lead who frequents brothels but is secretly a hero in the making
Male and female servants who constantly egg on the main leads in romance in a VERY unsubtle way
If you are travelling through any wood or forest look out for ninja warrior attacks!
The elders in xianxia series generally do not listen to reason…
Lots of men with long white hair (!) VERY few of whom but some, like Tan Jianci (Lost You Forever) and Joseph Zeng (Feud – a show I do not recommend) look unexpectedly hot, and slightly better than with real hair colour! haha
Oh… how could I forget?
Hero cares for Female, and Female tends to Male, when wounded, with white powder in a little round clay/china bottle with a red fabric stopper or a flatter decorated china/metal container . This is for flesh wounds and the ML always bears this process with a subtle wince unless he is the 2ML when he is sometimes more comedic and yelps. Modern shows make ample use of red antiseptic gel lotion applied with what looks like an extended cotton bud. More subtle wincing and greater likelihood of squeals from FL.
Someone ALWAYS gets a fever and the other someone very often falls asleep at their bedside overnight. This is very often a turning point in the romance.
Pretty well every first kiss opportunity is interrupted by a) a national crisis, b) intrusive man or woman servant or c) a mobile phone call!
Penny dropped! The red lotion used in modern day dramas is probably some type of iodine-based lotion or tincture.
Oh yes, I forgot about those, @Nicole.
➡️Virginal lead characters:
The man is celibate.
The woman is chaste.
🙂That’s from the Chinese gov’t instruction manual for fostering good citizenry.
➡️The women having great business sense is a “relatively” new addition. I’m seeing more and more historicals about enterprising women. In the beginning, they’re thrust in a situation where they have to fend for themselves then at the end, they become financially independent. They’re very business savvy, sometimes even more so than the men.
The lead in “Are You the One” established her own pottery in a town known for pottery, and became the guild leader, though the elderly townsmen resisted.
Yes! I love these Lantern festivals.
They’re the cdrama equivalent of the kdrama’s obligatory trip to that amusement park Everland. 😂
Yes, to brothels, too. I think it’s their version of a coffeeshop. Sooner or later, everybody meets there, even the female lead, and exchanges info.
😂😂 The fever trope is funny.
Did you also notice that the sick person must always take SIPS of that herbal medicine and complain of the bitter taste afterwards? If I were sick, I’d just drink the whole thing in one shot.
Also, the interrupted kiss. 😂😂
What a fun post!
To add to the elaborate hairdo trope and jade ornament trope, the use of hairpins as a symbolic object-gift from a parent or a lover. Also flowers as symbols.
Weddings- beautiful red dresses, face fans, carriage, listening outside the bridal chamber, visiting the parents the morning after, being hounded about having children
SPOILER PoB Similar to kramas , one can predict who will die by the way a protracted departure scene is done. In PoB it was the fat comedian Wei. Also there is often the death of the sweetest most innocent person.
Trusty(usually) lifelong personaL/ military assistant
Evil Eunuch. I read that eunuchs had a lot of power in the palace because those higher up were often subjected to periodic purges and eunuchs would stay in place for long periods of time. Not sure if this is true and there were other factors I m sure.
Romantic or not so romantic boat scenes. Bridge scenes. Dilapidated old house.
S**y armour and horse riding! In addition to the princess carry there is the swept up onto a horse with the hero trope and variations of this. Also in kdramas as are some of these other tropes.
@pacmule I see you also noticed the scene where he rises like the god Poseiden from the water or at least that is how I saw it. In the princess carry scene,I also wondered why he did not immediately cover her up to protect her from the rain.
@kate About ninja attacks, most likely when they have stopped somewhere along the road to take a break.
Also hiding items in the bed or bedchamber. Sometimes a breeze blows them to another location and a misunderstanding ensues.
Someone is set up by another leaving an item in their palace room, often by a servant acting on another’s direction.
@Packmule –
– The reluctant sips of herbal medicine (sometimes with shy glances through eyelashes) and comments about its bitterness… haha
I vote also for gulping it all back! Best option.
This is indeed a fun and cathartic conversation!
Enduring tropes or tropes we endure?!
@Monmor,
I do wonder why they take breaks in densely forested areas!
Weddings! Yes. I wonder just how many traditional Chinese weddings we have all seen over the years! I see so many that I find myself rating the ceremony!! Also the long wait the bride has while the groom goes off to drink with family and friends…will the bridegroom disappear off to his office to do some urgent military planning on the wedding night? Will he actually show up for the bride sober and in the right mood??? .
@kate One or both of them sitting awkwardly at the bottom of the bed Oh waiting the big C.🤣
*waiting for the big
C
@Packmule3, to add to the kneeling punishment: arms held up, or even some object (basin of water, usually) held overhead. I have seen punishment of kneeling with arms up in Kdramas set in schools.
When the camera pans to the moon, it is (almost) always full. That messes with timeline a bit, since the moon is full every 29.5 days. In the world of a drama, the full moon appears whenever art direction deems it necessary for mood, ignoring moon phases on which timekeeping hinges.
Here’s a trope I see a lot, probably not limited to Cdramas: gossiping huddles of people, usually women, who speak loudly enough to be overheard by the subject of their gossip.
Also, the mean girl has her sycophants who don’t question her instant animosity for the FL, just amplify it. But that seems to be a trope seen across many cultures.
Listing the ways I laughed in order — giggle, chuckle, chuckle, belly laugh, more giggling, more belly laughing and finally rolling back and forth holding my stomach.
Thank you. A precious experience.
@Packmule3, it may not be only in Cdramas, but to me there seems to be an excessive number of times drinking glasses are clinked. And it’s not just when drinking alcohol: even tea cups get clinked.
Love all these, completely on point for CDrama Historicals. Also, hysterical that you mentioned the Kdrama trope of the yellow umbrella too. I put them on my covers of my books for my “Time Spent Under” series, not to signify the typical meaning of whoever is under them will share a love / bond that is deep and unbroken but other meanings such as to shield, to protect and shelter and to evoke feelings of melancholy. So many people have commented to me that I must be a hardcore KDrama fan to use them but I’m a fan of all dramas (and tropes):)