I’m convinced that viewers who claim to “hate” this kdrama are either uninterested in (or worse, incapable of) discerning the moral and ethical underpinnings of the show. Meanwhile, I dropped the Japanese version because it’s a straight-up workplace satire with formulaic plots; it wasn’t thought-provoking enough for me. To each his own.
As I expected, these last two episodes dwelled on two issues:
a. whether or not it’s moral/ethical of SuJeong (SJ) and Dr. Jo (Jo) to kill their patient KSH to avenge his young victims, and
b. whether or not SJ and Jo should feel guilty and complicit in the KSH’s crime for not actively intervening to stop him from preying on kids.
And as I predicted, the short answers are:
a. No, it’s utterly immoral/unethical for a doctor to kill her patient.
b. Yes, absolutely. SJ and Jo should feel guilty for their failure to protect the children.
I’m relieved to know that I read the mind of the show’s creators’ perfectly.
1. Doctors can’t kill their patients.
SJ believed in this moral precept, too.
Intern Park begged to be part of KSH’s surgery because he sensed that SJ and Dr. Jo would do the unthinkable, i.e., first-degree murder, to avenge him and the other victims. But SJ blocked him with a simple statement.
SJ: Your hands are the hands of a doctor. They should be used to save lives.
This means:
a. She knew she was about to commit a grave offense that was contrary to moral code. By breaking the core tenet of the Hippocratic oath, she was “un-doctor”-ing herself. The career-ending consequences were irrelevant to her. For sure, the hospital administration would fire and the medical board would revoke her license. But it didn’t matter to her because she was voluntarily self-exiling.
b. She believed that un-doctoring is the:
only remedy,
just punishment, and
needed penance
for failing in her responsibility and duty to protect the children in her care. In her mind, that’s the reason, she had no dreams of Baraka. It weighed on her conscience that she saw the signs but didn’t grasp the full situation until it was too late because she idolized KSH.
What were the signs?
Baraka asking her if Baba was good
Neema rubbing her buttocks, and saying that Baraka did a “no-no”
Neema saying that Baraka went to KSH night and day but wasn’t getting better
Neema mentioning Baraka went to KSH to “doctor play”
Baraka being sleepy at breakfast
Baraka asking her if there’s another place they could go to
Baraka putting a protective arm around Neema after KSH approached the child
Baraka clenching the lighter in his fist
Note: “Doctor play” sounds like an innocent pretend game for children. Medical check-ups can be scary for kids so one way to ease their anxiety is to role-play a doctor and use stuffed toys or parents as patients. However, a pedophile can use this innocent game to normalize physical contact with the child, get him/her to undress, and then later molest and sexually abuse the child.
c. As long as SJ could avenge Intern Park and the victims, she was willing to sacrifice her life’s work.
And the screenwriters made sure that SJ has a perfectly valid excuse to kill him on the operating table. KSH was shown to be unrepentant and irredeemable till the end. In their last encounter by his bedside before the surgery, KSH displayed no remorse as he talked about Baraka.
SJ: It’s a miracle we made it this far alive, you and I.
KSH: (patting her hand) I had them buried…those shoes…buried with Baraka. That’s when I heard it. That’s when God forgave me. The children’s letters. Look at the children’s letters. They love me. Those children.
SJ: (aghast)
In my opinion, there was really no need for this sort of revelation, but it’s a plot contrivance meant to:
show that he was a psychopath who would never stop his sexual abuse of children, and
trigger SJ’s revulsion and harden her resolve to kill him.
Technically speaking, this scene is similar to Darth Vader in Star Wars, goading Luke into anger by threatening to turn his sister Leia to the dark side. Darth Vader wanted Luke to “snap” so Luke would find himself falling to the dark side.
Same thing happened in this scene. The screenwriter showed KSH pushing SJ’s button so SJ would have no qualms killing him. By bringing up Baraka, KSH wanted SJ to acknowledge that the two of them were cut from the same cloth. They were both loved by children. Naturally, this comparison nauseated SJ, but she didn’t show it to KSH.
SJ: Why? Why did you choose me?
KSH: You always save all of your patients, no matter who they are.
KSH meant that SJ didn’t make moral judgments on her patients. KSH chose her precisely because he was a 100% certain that she wouldn’t kill him despite knowing of his sexual abuses.
See how vile this man is? He was manipulating – and perverting – the Hippocratic oath to his advantage.
KSH: (continuing) You’re the one most like me. You’re my finest, most brilliant student. There is no such thing as failure. That’s who Gye SuJeong is.
SJ: Right. That’s exactly what I wanted to hear.
He assumed that she would be honored to be told that she was his replica, when in reality, his praise just hardened her heart and galvanized her determination to eliminate him.
Hence, SJ replayed this dialogue in her head as she began the surgery to remind herself that this was a morally depraved man deserving of death in her hands.
Fortunately, Ms. Jang stepped in.
Jang: No, Gye SuJeong! SuJeong!
And she brought Neema. The little girl waved “hello” then patted her heart.

To me, this gesture might be small, but it was a profound reminder for SJ. Three reasons:
a. SJ remembered teaching her the sign for “heart” after her recovery from the gunshot to the head.
b. I also think SJ was reminded of the way she always touched her patients’ hearts after surgery. I’ve always thought her gesture was a sign of REVERENCE for the life she’s worked so hard to save, and GRATITUDE that the patient’s heart listened to her unsaid prayer to live.
c. Most of all, Neema’s hand-to-heart gesture reminded SJ that she was a doctor who saved lives.
Jang: I brought her here. I asked her to come. To hold you back. To… to keep you from doing this.
pic
Note: in Episode 11, Ms Jang (or Dr. Jang as she was back then) scolded SJ for performing surgery on a patient who had terminal cancer and couldn’t sleep lying down because of tumor. SJ said it was the least they could do for the patient and KSH said he would’ve done it like that back in the day. Ms. Jang questioned KSH’s motive, however, and asked SJ whether the surgery was performed to add to operation to the Doctor X database (which I’m assuming was a compilation of “heroic surgeries” done by doctors of the White Wings Medical Corps, not just SJ). Then, Ms. Jang asked SJ whether her curiosity about surgery her real motivation was for operating on the man. Though SJ denied it, Ms. Jang’s parting shot was “You need to ask yourself, honestly, as to whether that surgery sincerely was for your patient, or for your own sake.” That stunned SJ.
Back in the present, it’s clear to me that SJ was performing the surgery for her sake. If she wanted vengeance for the victims, then she should let KSH live to hear from his victim, shatter his delusion of being “loved,” and see his legacy destroyed. In my opinion, killing him was to appease her personal guilt for being unable to save Baraka.
Just as SJ was about to relent and spare KSH’s life, the “zealots” faction from the White Wings Medical Corps appeared out of the blue. And their appearance hardened her resolve once again.
She threatened to stop the surgery which in effect would kill KSH.
SJ: If you lay a finger on Neema, I won’t do anything. I may be Baba’s favorite student, but Baba is not my teacher.
To me, she was letting them know two things:
a. If Baba had drilled into his medical students to save their patients “no matter who they are,” then she didn’t subscribe to that idea because he didn’t train her. As White Wings Medical Corps held Baba to godlike status, she was telling them that she was nothing like Baba. She was lunatic as they come so they shouldn’t test her.
b. She had no connection to the man, so she felt no compulsion to save him. She didn’t worship him like his “zealots” did.
2. Intern Park and Neema in the Upper Deck of the operating theater
I thought this was genius staging ground (or setting) for three reasons.
a. It’s a visual metaphor.
Intern Park and Neema = angels looking down on SJ and Dr. Jo
Intern Park and Neema were KSH’s victims. But they were telling SJ and Dr. Jo that it was okay to let go of vengeance, that they didn’t have to kill KSH for their sake, that they needed not feel guilty anymore for failing to stop KSH.
Neema was a former resident of the “White Wings” hospital. Angels are portrayed as having white wings. Neema is like a putto (or a chubby winged baby angel) guiding SJ to the right path.

Note: When I visited Lisbon a few years ago, I took a photo of these putti surrounding a mural on the ceiling. This is how Neema would have looked like to SJ when SJ gazed at the glass ceiling above her. Neema would resemble a baby angel in the sky.

b. It flips Nietzsche’s famous quote about looking into abyss.
“Whoever battles monsters should ensure they do not become a monster themselves; looking long into the abyss causes the abyss to look into you.” – Friedrich Nietzsche

Fortunately, SJ didn’t look down into an abyss. Instead, she was made to gaze up at the glass ceiling because Intern Park and Neema tapped on the glass. She was reminded about who she truly was. She wasn’t a monster, but a doctor saving lives.






According to Nietzche,
Looking into the abyss = turning themselves into monsters
Because they had unresolved guilt from their failure to stop KSH, SJ and Dr. Jo were in danger of becoming monsters. If they had killed KSH out of vengeance, they fell into the abyss.
However, according to the screenwriter and director,
Looking upwards (or heavenward) = being true to themselves — doctors who saved lives
Lol. Didn’t you notice how many angles the director used to show SJ looking up or heavenwards? I think there’s a point here: we can live with monsters or we can look up to something good and noble and inspirational.
c. Neema’s colorful artwork = God’s message for SJ
Her artwork not only reminded me of a painted ceiling in chapels and basilica, but it also brought to mind the rainbow in the sky after the Great Flood.


In the Bible, God had told Noah to build an ark for him, his family and pairs of every animal as He would send the Great Flood to cleanse the world of evil. Afterwards, God placed a rainbow in the sky as a promise that He would never again destroy the world.
The rainbow then became a symbol of divine grace and mercy.
Like the rainbow in the sky, Neema’s colorful artwork on the glass ceiling is God’s message for SJ.

I’m glad that Dr. Jo pointed this out to SJ who hated God.
Jo: Do you think God exists?
SJ: Would it matter if He did?
Jo: Do you believe in God?
SJ: I hate Him.
Jo: Hmmmm. Well, God believes in you. I guess that’s why He stopped by down there. “Leave me to deal with him. You just carry on doing your work. Be a doctor just a little while longer.”
My four comments:
First, Dr. Jo’s statement about leaving God to deal with KSH is a diluted version of what the apostle Paul said in his letter to the Romans. He told them to trust in God’s justice.
“Beloved, never avenge yourselves, but leave it to the wrath of God; for it is written, ‘Vengeance is mine, I will repay, says the Lord.’”
Second, SJ hated God because she couldn’t understand the existence of evil, and in particular evil men like KSH who used God’s name as license to do evil.
Too bad, but not unusual for many people.
Third, God wants us to overcome evil, NOT by evil, but with good.
SJ, Dr. Jo, and Intern Park almost forgot that. Good thing Ms. Jang and Neema saved them.
And last, when the viewers reflect on this, they’ll see that God’s love for mankind has a few things in common with SJ’s medical service to her patients. They’re both unconditional, steadfast, and sacrificial.
3. Culpability of the “secondary monsters”
If you noticed, all three adults whom I said were “secondary monsters” apologized to Intern Park individually in this episode.
a. Dr. Jo.
b. Ms. Jang. She apologized to Neema and Intern Park.
Jang: I apologize. I’m so sorry. It’s all my fault. I’m sorry.

c. and SJ.
Intern Park: I want to be there in the OR. Why won’t you allow it? What’s the reason? Why do I have to stay in the donor’s OR?
SJ and Jo: (not answering)
Park: I want to go in too. I can’t let you two go in there alone.
Jo: Why do you keep insisting? Do you realize… Do you really need to be part of this?
She couldn’t even say exactly what methods they’d take to punish KSH.
Park: Yes, I won’t let it go. You two are doing this because you won’t let it go either.
SJ and Jo: (walking away)
Park: After this, your careers are over! I know that you think this surgery will be the last one for the two of you. You don’t know how many more kids like me are out there. And since you can’t bring him to justice, you’re going into that OR and risking it all. That doesn’t seem fair to me. So I’ll risk it all, too. Let’s do this together.
Why does Intern Park mean by they “can’t bring him to justice”? Well, I think KSH’s crimes are too wicked, too widespread, too horrific that no earthly punishment fits him. It’s in situation like this that we hope that God exists, because only a Divine and Eternal Judge can deliver the ultimate justice.
SJ turned around to face Intern Park. She recalled what Baraka once told her. He wanted to become a doctor like Gye SuJeong; that was his dream. As SJ couldn’t make Baraka’s dream come true, she wouldn’t allow Intern Park’s dream to become a doctor be broken, too.
SJ: Your hands… are the hands of a doctor. They should be used to save lives.
Dr. Jo remembered how she couldn’t grab a hold of her childhood friend’s hand when she jumped off the ledge. Her hand was useless back then.
SJ: This is a desperate attempt. One that’s made in memory of those who needed help, those we let slip away and couldn’t save.
And in a brief flashback, we saw Baraka’s hand dropped to the ground. Now, remember the three-point explanation in the beginning of this post.
SJ: And at this point, things are up to us. We desperately need to do something. No matter the cost. (walking away)


Yes! That’s what they should have done when they found out about KSH’s pedophilia and sexual abuse. “No matter the cost,” the man should have exposed and made accountable.
Jo: I was thinking about the timing… I mean, uh, the sequence of events back then. That if I had known about it sooner…I mean, you might not…Um…I…I might have been able to put an end to it.
Park: (tearing up)
Jo: I shouldn’t be saying this to you. I should be asking myself that over and over, as a constant reminder, as a way of punishing myself.
Park: Dr. Jo, please let me join you, okay? What if I assist you? Tell me what to do and I’ll do it, please?
Jo: Oh, no. Not you. Just let the two of us do it ourselves. Let us save you from this, okay?
And to me, this is the sign that she was taking responsibility for her failure in the past to step in. She had walked away from her family after discovering her father’s crime, and blocked it from her mind, when it stood to reason that something HAD to be done. Dr. Jo and SJ were adults when they learned what was happening. They should have exposed KSH. In cases like this, following the “three wise monkeys” – you know the monkeys who see no evil, hear no evil, and speak no evil — wasn’t the wise and compassionate thing to do.

Jo: So when this is all through…um…Park TaeGyeong will still be here. Let us do that for you.
4. Reason for not seeing Baraka
I think SJ’s guilt prevented her from seeing Baraka in her dreams. So, it made for a great “footnote” to her story, when Neema tapped the rug where they were sitting on, and she dreamed of Baraka appearing her dreams that night. To me, it meant that Baraka was with her all along. It was her mind (or should I say, conscience) that made him invisible to her.
5. The optimistic message for survivors
Park: My parents know. I told them everything.
His mother wrote, “My dear TaeGyeong, God will always be with you. He is there whenever there is love. We love you.”


Park: They thanked me for persevering, and not giving up on this world. So now I’ll… I’ll do my best to be brave.
My comments:
a. It’s interesting that Intern Park didn’t relay his mom’s message out loud. He let Dr. Jo take a glimpse of the text message, but he said something entirely different to SJ. He probably knew what SJ thought about gods (or demi-gods) after KSH and White Wings Medical Corp mess.
A lot of good, and a lot of bad had been done in the name of religion. Yes, KSH abused the children, but there were doctors like Ms. Jang and SJ, and Intern Park’s parents, I presumed, who believed in the humanitarian cause of “White Wings” and provided selfless acts of charity and even fostered/adopted the children without doing them harm. It’s illogical to blame evil actions, and their consequences, on God when humans, not God, commit the evil deeds.
b. That’s the same message for the Gwangju survivor, Mr. Oh, isn’t it? When life seems impossible because of the terrible weight of the past, try to brave it out just one day at a time. Thinking of the future when one has trauma to survive through can often become debilitating and overwhelming. Perhaps focusing on doing your best in the present moment works better for healing.
6. Continuation hook?
The ending wrapped up all the major conflicts. However, I think the major characters “rode off” into the sunset while leaving open the possibility of their return in the future.
Final grade: A
Leave a Reply