Crash Landing on You: Episode 10, part 2

I said I had 10 things to bitch about, didn’t I? I only gave my first five so here’s the last five.

Crash Landing on You: Episode 10, part 1

5. The Overrated Moment

I already wrote about here, Crash Landing on You: Ep 10, The Reunion

I can only take so much over-the-top heroics. There are still three weeks or 6 episodes to go. The director should scale down on these Rambo-style rescue missions and go back to basics.

I didn’t sign up for this:

Image result for rambo rescue gif

I want more of these scenes:

gif credit: xiaozhanns’ tumblr

4. The mother-and-daughter drama

Please don’t drag this drama till the end.

Aside from JungHyuk, Seri’s weak spot is her “fake” mother. I was shaking my hand when she played the aggrieved daughter. She didn’t question for a second whether she got hold of the wrong end of the stick, and her mother had been worried about her disappearance. Her mother audibly released a deep breath upon seeing her.

That could have been a sigh of relief, but she construed it to be sigh of exasperation because she was apologizing afterwards.

SR: I’m sorry, Mom.
Mom: What do you mean?
SR: Did you hope that I would come back? When my company’s stock price bottomed out, a lot of people bought a lot of stocks dirt cheap. Among them, Sang-a bought the largest number of stocks. And you were next in line.
Mom: That was–
SR: I grew that company all on my own. It doesn’t belong to your kids. It belongs to me. Did you want to take my company away from me, too?
Mom: Seri-ya.
SR: Ah. Because you thought I was dead? Okay. Yes. It’s understandable. It’s understandable but you liked it, didn’t you? (her mother frowned) You thought I was dead, and you liked it, didn’t you? (and her mother inhaled) That’s why I said I’m sorry. I’m sorry I came back alive and hurt your feelings.

Then the mother didn’t join the family for dinner.

She didn’t consider that her mother bought her company’s stocks so her sister-in-law wouldn’t get her hands on her company and to protect her ownership until she reappeared.

I’m losing patience with the ambiguity of their relationship. Since Episode 1, we knew that there’s more to their mother-and-daughter relationship than meets the eye: a stepmother who set her nonbiological daughter as #1 on her speed-dial; a stepmother who was more distraught than the biological father about her disappearance; a stepmother who step in to protect her nonbiological daughter’s assets; and a stepmother who shared her memories of being lost at the beach.

Hmmm…did the stepmother feel guilty because she was the one who abandoned her at the beach?

While I don’t want the stepmother to be conveniently written off as a modern-day version of Grimm fairy tale evil stepmother, I also don’t want their history to be too complicated that the focus on the kdrama will shift towards the repair of their relationship.

3. Seri’s father

This one is odd, too.

Since Episode 2, we’ve been led to believe that the father is Seri’s biological parent. There was the fortune-telling ceremony when she was a year old, and she chose her dad’s hand.

In Episode 4, Brother #1 accused the mother of wanting to abandon Seri after their Father brought her home. His father conveniently stopped him from dwelling on it.

In Episode 8, after Seri’s death had been announced to the board, Secretary Hong wanted to approach the father with proof of Seri’s existence. He ruled out informing the mother because she wasn’t the biological parent.

Insurance guy: Let’s visit her mother. She gave birth to her. She’ll definitely recognize her daughter’s voice.
Hong: She’s not the birth mother. I found out not too long ago.
Insurance guy: Then how about the chairman? He’s her biological father, right?
Hong: You’ve finally gone insane. How could we possible meet him?

Then, in Episode 10, Brother #1 asked their Father point-blank when he had found that Seri was alive.

Seri glanced at her Brother #1. I suspect that this was news to her, too.

Their father glanced to his left, where Seri and Brother #2 were seated. I think he was looking at Brother #2 who in turn was studiously avoiding eye contact.

Father: (evasively) Why is that important?
Brother #1: It was that time, right? Was it about two weeks ago?

Seri, who had been looking at her Brother #1, rolled her eyes down.

This could be interpreted as Seri realizing that her father had known for two weeks that she was alive.

Brother #1: (continuing) You went on a business trip for three or four days. And you didn’t come back home.
Father: Well, that’s not important. Let’s not talk about –
Seri: (stepping in) Yes, it was probably then. It was when I was in the hospital….(starts talking about her amnesia and company chairmanship)

I hope many of you found this conversation bizarre like I did.

Did you see what she did here? She attacked her stepmother for thinking she was DEAD, but she passively accepted that her “real” father had known that she was ALIVE.

Did that make sense?

Put yourself in Seri’s shoes and think about this again. On one hand, you have a nonbiological parent who thought you were dead and bought your stocks. You get mad at her and accuse her of wanting you dead.

But on the other hand, you have a biological parent who knew you were alive but didn’t do anything to rescue you. You let him get away with it. You don’t start accusing him of wanting you dead. You don’t rant at him for leaving you alone to rot in North Korea. You calmly change topic and discuss business.

Image result for what's wrong with that gif

Seri’s thought-process doesn’t add up.

2. JungHyuk’s dad

I’m going to be a minority here. I don’t care if he loves his son and his wife. To me, he raises a red flag. If I had a daughter, there was no way I’d allow her to marry into this family unless some conditions were met to my satisfaction.

Fact: The father ordered Seri kidnapped at gunpoint.

One, I understand that this is a trope. The Kidnapping plot is often seen in makjang or soap-opera-ish kdramas. It’s acceptable convention.

Two, I understand that the screenwriter tried to present the mastermind, JungHyuk’s father, as a concerned and benevolent parent. As the director of the politburo, JungHyuk’s father was well within his rights to be concern about his son’s liaison and the repercussions of his consorting with a South Korean woman.

And three, I also understand that many viewers believed that the father had an UNIMPEACHABLE motivation for committing an otherwise irreprehensible act. The father’s motives could be viewed as logical, understandable, urgent, or excusable.

But I can tell you that his father could be charged with abduction, false imprisonment, and second-degree kidnapping. Without even needing Gorilla Glue, these charges would stick on him. In all honesty, I found that this whole kidnapping trope exposes JungHyuk’s father’s moral turpitude. I don’t approve of his decisions, and his action raises a red flag.

Image result for raise a red flag gif

Think about this: if JungHyuk’s father can order the kidnapping of a grown woman, what will stop him from ordering the kidnapping of a young child?

When JungHyuk and Seri marry and have a child of their own, they can’t rule out child abduction by the grandparent. JungHyuk’s father can decide to kidnap his grandchild for some trumped-up reason, and he has the power and the resources to remove the grandchild from his natural home, and hide him in an inaccessible place. Ugh! Dangerous in-law.

Related image

Kidnapping is never a good trope, and I wish the writer didn’t use it to “humanize” JungHyuk’s father … or to get JungHyuk back to North Korea again.

1. Prayer bowl

JungHyuk’s squad were wondering where he was. One of them reported that he couldn’t eat nor sleep, and they’ve never seen such love sickness before. As they spoke, JungHyuk was at the hut, sitting near the pray bowl. He imagined Seri beside him.

SR: I heard what this is. Someone offered prayers with water. Pyo Chisoo told me earlier. There lived a mother with a son who went to war 60 years ago here.
JH: I know that.
SR: I wonder if the mother met her son. If I await desperately with prayers, will I be able to meet someone I miss?
JH: You do it to live. If you give up on waiting, the pain of loss will kill you. That’s why you wait.

He looked back and her vision had disappeared. He looked at the prayer bowl again.

The reason I’m annoyed with this scene is that there were two levels of interpreting this scene, and people got the first one easily, but not the second one.

On the surface, Seri was talking about their romance.

But on a deeper level, the story was talking about the tragedy that for more than half a century now, families have remained separated on either side of the 38th parallel.

After I heard about the uproar over the sympathetic depiction of North Korea in this kdrama, I’m aghast at how uncompassionate some people could be. It baffles me that they can’t and won’t understand that two nations may forever coexist as separate geo-political entities, but their citizens have life expectancy. They don’t have an eternity to coexist as separate families.

To me, this rice bowl scene was alluding to that.

As I’ve written a long time ago, majority of the separated family members are well into their 80s and they would like to see their loves ones before they die. At the very least, these two governments should prioritize the reunions of these elderly folks for humanitarian reasons. In my opinion, should this kdrama raise awareness about these survivors’ last request, and move even 0.01% of the population to see the urgency of their cause, then this kdrama has done a good deed.

11 Comments On “Crash Landing on You: Episode 10, part 2”

  1. Thank you for this food for thought. Ref Seri and her father: I thought she might be covering for him and that’s why she’s not blaming him. Perhaps he met her at the border; they had to go through some debriefing that needed to be kept secret, or maybe something else?

    Ref JH’s father: one thing that really made me feel odd was the CCTV in the room where Seri was first kept. She mustn’t have been the first one there.

    Ref Seri’s step-mum: (warning – complete, utter ramble) if by chance she is Seri’s real mother, what happened at the time of the birth and why would Seri have been separated from the family for a while before being ‘brought back’ by her dad? If that’s true, there must be a reason for Seri to be kept in the dark about this? Is the ‘step mom’ the female double agent mentioned in an early episode? Might Seri have been born north of the border?

    Thanks also for pointing out the 2nd rice bowl interpretation. There is so much of this going on in different places around the globe right now. I wonder how many people who are watching in SK/NK will think of this; might it make a difference in attitude and policy?

  2. Love your comment about folks thinking JH’s dad had an “unimpeachable” offense. I thought the writer used this as a way to get Seri out of JH’s house so she was not caught by the bad guy. Nonetheless, I agree that it’s dangerous to let this act slide for whatever trumped-up nonsense.

    I was actually thinking about the second interpretation during that prayer bowl scene. It was very sad. I felt as though some people have accepted the separation. How can this be?

    Thanks again for your insightful observations.

  3. I truly appreciate the fact that you beautifully captured the 2nd interpretation. I’m Vietnamese who was brought here ( California) in April of 1975. The Vietnamese has the 17th parallel instead of the 38th in Korea…It’s hard to be caught between…as I came back in 2016 for the first time. I stood in the middle of the bridge…trying to image how people from both sides have felt…based on the stories were told from my parents generation… I’m not qualified to judge because I was raised in America but I definitely was feeling uncomfortable…and heavy in my heart…

    Hopefully, there will be a better chance for these Korean families to meet once again before they departed….

  4. The name of the bridge is the Bến Hải river and in Korea there’s the Han River ..

  5. Additional
    The name of the bridge is the Bến Hải river and in Korea there’s the Han River ..

  6. I am one of the people who thought JH dad’s actions were excusable. But I didn’t think of his as the in-law (because I have no brain left to think?) Now that I do think however, I would forbid such type of union with my daughter (as is possible in my culture 😝) His actions are not excusable.

    Thank you for making me think 🙂

    Thank you for making me think.

  7. I’m sure JH’s father intended to do more to her than just kidnap her at gunpoint. Get rid of her somehow. It seemed like he considered murder.
    He changed his mind because of his wife and probably partly because of the conversation with her
    So of course he doesn’t make a good family to marry into but that’s no fault of JH and I can’t really care about that. Maybe because I’m not a parent.
    She has an equally horrible family anyway. Even much worse actually because unlike JH’s father SeRi’s brother and father do not have the cruel environment in NK to force them into doing unacceptable stuff in order to survive.

    “But on a deeper level, the story was talking about the tragedy that for more than half a century now, families have remained separated on either side of the 38th parallel.” – this I thought was pretty obvious in that scene. Why people decided to talk only about the love part I don’t know but they can’t have missed on this

    As I had a problem with everyone being overly excited to see all the gang in South Korea while I watched that scene at the end of episode 10 thinking only of how horrible it would be for JH not to return. Now he’s not only putting his family in danger by going to SK but all these guys’ families as well.

  8. Hello,

    If I may clarify, with regards to her father. From my understanding of the dinner scene, it seems like it was 2 weeks after Seri left NK. While the show did not explicitly tell/show us the clip how Seri was brought back home, we were given clues on what might have happened.
    1) Father left ‘somewhere’ 2 weeks ago for 3-4 days
    2) She claimed she was in hospital past 2 weeks – supposedly had amnesia no idea what happened prior (ie during the past month she went missing)

    So my take away was after she parted with JH at the border – she must have met with the patrolling SK army as instructed by JH. However of course SK army needs to verify her identity first. She must have contacted her father then. So father went for ‘business trip’ to actually rescue Seri at the border. This was of course done in secret without any visibility to the brothers. She must not want to reveal that she went to NK to SK army since that will get her suspected as being a spy. So she prolly said she got lost and use the amnesia route. Or even if she did reveal to SK army, this is sensitive issue she will be placed under probation and inspection) because theres a high chance she was a spy anyway (hence the two weeks quarantined may be). SK army prolly would not want to reveal this to public as it will be controversial, so prolly favour with Seri pretending to be amnesic too. Anyway either way the show did not dwells on this. So the key point is, Father somehow rescues Seri. He may or may not know the full stories (NK stories and the truth behind amnesia) but key point was he did rescued her. Father prolly really glad that she was alive, that is much more important than what exactly the truth behind it.

    When she came back, making her appearance at her company- this was news to everyone (but not to father). And she claimed she was in hospital and being amnesia past 2 weeks. It was also advertised that she had no idea and also no one knows what happened the past month essentially.

    During the dinner, bro 1 had suspected Father knew she was alive earlier (precisely 2 weeks ago because he went away) not just recently like him. Since father did not want to reveal much, he just slide it and say it was not important. That’s why the mood during the dinner was like that and that Seri was not hostile to the father.

    That was my interpretation. Thanks

  9. Your theory works. 👍👍 Thanks for sharing!

  10. Not that it matters a lot, but there is a problem with the dates. Seri left NK no earlier than Dec. 28, because she was abducted on Christmas Day, spent two nights in RJH’s parent’s house (12/25 and 12/26), then another day in the DMZ (12/27), before crossing the border near dawn on 12/28. We then know that she looked at her phone while lying in bed on 1/7, which was at least several days after she announced her return at the Seri’s Choice building. So the period between her crossing the border and her announcement could only have been about a week. I’m not sure why the writers made it two weeks. It couldn’t have been that long.

  11. Good point. Thanks for bringing this up. I sensed that there was something off about the two weeks time lapse. But I was too lazy to backtrack and get the dates right.

Comments are closed.